
FAIR is a non-profit organization dedicated to providing well-documented answers to criticisms of the doctrine, practice, and history of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.
FAIR › Scripture Study Resources: Supplement Your Come, Follow Me Study › Study Resources for the Old Testament & Pearl of Great Price › Week 51 I Have Loved You, Saith the Lord
Malachi
In Malachi 1:2, the Lord declares, “I have loved you,” yet Israel responds by asking, “Wherein hast thou loved us?” Their question illustrates how hardship and spiritual distance can make it difficult to recognize the Lord’s love. The history of Israel demonstrates that God continues to reach out to His people despite their weaknesses, offering opportunities to repent, receive His mercy, and renew their relationship with Him.
In Malachi 3:7, the Lord extends this invitation: “Return unto me, and I will return unto you.” His invitation shows that repentance is not merely about correcting mistakes; it is an opportunity to restore our relationship with Him. As we examine our choices, priorities, and attitudes, we can identify ways to respond to His love and invite His influence more fully into our lives.
In Malachi 1:6–14, the Lord challenges the priests for presenting offerings that dishonor Him rather than demonstrating genuine reverence. Malachi 1:11 teaches that the Lord’s name will be great among the nations and that a pure offering will be presented unto Him. These teachings invite us to examine not only what we give the Lord but also the spirit in which we give it, including the quality of our service, time, worship, and obedience.
In Malachi 3:8–12, the Lord teaches His people to bring their tithes into the storehouse and promises to open the windows of heaven. Elder Neil L. Andersen explains that these blessings may be temporal or spiritual, and some may be subtle or difficult to recognize immediately. Tithing is therefore more than a financial obligation; it is a way to put the Lord first and trust that He knows our needs. The promise of blessings should not be interpreted as a guarantee of wealth or freedom from every hardship, but as an invitation to exercise faith in the Lord.
In Malachi 4:5–6, the Lord promises to send Elijah before the great and dreadful day of the Lord, explaining that he will turn the hearts of the fathers to the children and the hearts of the children to their fathers. This prophecy points to a work that reaches beyond our mortal lives and connects us with our family history and eternal responsibilities. As we learn about our ancestors and participate in family history and temple service, we help fulfill the purposes of this prophecy.
The book of Malachi addresses a covenant people whose religious practices did not always reflect sincere devotion to God. The Lord challenged the priests for offering blemished sacrifices (Malachi 1:6–14), called the people to return to Him (Malachi 3:7), taught the importance of tithing (Malachi 3:8–12), and prophesied the coming of Elijah (Malachi 4:5–6). These teachings addressed both immediate spiritual problems and the Lord’s broader purposes for His covenant people.
Malachi’s teachings about tithing reveal that covenant faithfulness is fundamentally about trusting the Lord and aligning our hearts with Him.
In Malachi 3:8–12, the Lord challenges Israel to bring its tithes into the storehouse and promises to pour out blessings upon the faithful. Understanding the historical and spiritual context helps us recognize that the people were being invited to return to the Lord through concrete acts of covenant obedience. Elder Neil L. Andersen reinforces this principle in “Tithing: Opening the Windows of Heaven,” teaching that the blessings of tithing come in many forms, including spiritual strength, protection, and a diminished desire for material possessions. The promise is not that faithful people will never experience financial difficulty, but that the Lord’s blessings extend beyond what we can measure financially.
The phrase “windows of heaven” in Malachi 3:10 conveys the abundance of the Lord’s promised blessings. These blessings may include greater faith, peace, wisdom, spiritual resilience, and opportunities to serve others, even when our circumstances do not improve immediately.
Tithing also helps provide resources for the Lord’s work, including temples, missionary service, religious education, and assistance to people in need. As Elder Andersen explains, paying tithing is a way to put the Lord first rather than simply a means of obtaining material benefits. We demonstrate faith when we honor this commandment with sincere intent and trust the Lord’s timing.
The promise that Elijah would turn the hearts of fathers and children toward one another teaches that family relationships and temple ordinances are central to God’s eternal purposes.
Malachi 4:5–6 concludes the Old Testament with a prophecy that Elijah would come before the great and dreadful day of the Lord. This promise takes on additional meaning in latter-day scripture, which records Elijah’s appearance in the Kirtland Temple on April 3, 1836, and the restoration of the sealing keys (Doctrine and Covenants 110:13–16). Elder D. Todd Christofferson explains in “The Sealing Power” that this authority enables priesthood ordinances to be binding in heaven as well as on earth. The work connects living individuals with their deceased ancestors and provides the opportunity for families to be linked eternally through Jesus Christ.
The phrase “turn the heart” suggests more than collecting genealogical information. Family history and temple service can deepen our love for our ancestors, increase our understanding of our spiritual heritage, and motivate us to help them receive the blessings of sacred ordinances.
The sealing power also offers hope to individuals whose family circumstances are difficult, incomplete, or different from what they desire. Elder Christofferson emphasizes that God’s plan provides an opportunity for exaltation to those who faithfully keep their covenants, even when their present circumstances do not allow them to experience the ideal of an eternal family. Through Jesus Christ, we can trust in God’s perfect justice, mercy, and love as we work toward eternal relationships.
If you have questions on this week’s reading, please email your questions to us here.
Practical solutions for someone in faith crisis:
Action Step: Identify one area of your life where you can respond more fully to the Lord’s invitation to return to Him (Malachi 3:7).
Recognizing the Lord’s love can help us approach repentance with hope rather than discouragement. When we understand that He invites us to return, we can view spiritual growth as an opportunity to strengthen our relationship with Him instead of simply correcting our mistakes.
Encouraging Thought:
Action Step: Review your attitude toward tithing and identify one way you can make this commandment a more intentional expression of faith.
Tithing teaches us to trust the Lord with our resources and priorities. As Elder Neil L. Andersen explains in “Tithing: Opening the Windows of Heaven,” the blessings of tithing may be temporal or spiritual, and they do not always come in the form we expect. Faithful tithing can help us develop gratitude, generosity, and confidence in the Lord’s timing.
Encouraging Thought:
Malachi’s prophecy teaches that turning our hearts toward our families is part of the Lord’s work in the latter days. Family history and temple service can deepen our appreciation for those who came before us and help us understand the eternal purposes of the sealing power. These efforts can also provide hope to individuals whose family relationships have been difficult or incomplete.
Encouraging Thought:
Objective: Help learners understand how tithing demonstrates faith in the Lord and how His blessings may come in spiritual as well as temporal ways.
Activity Steps:
Follow-Up Question: How can we recognize the Lord’s blessings when they do not come in the form or timing we expected?
Objective: Help learners understand Elijah’s mission and identify practical ways to participate in family history and temple work
Activity Steps:
Introduction (5 min): Ask learners to think of someone in their family, past or present, who has influenced their life. Invite them to share a quality, tradition, or lesson they have received from that person. Explain that family connections are central to Malachi’s closing prophecy.
Scripture Discussion (5 min): Read Malachi 4:5–6 and Doctrine and Covenants 110:13–16. Discuss Elijah’s promised mission and the restoration of the sealing keys. Explain how family history and temple service provide opportunities to turn our hearts toward our ancestors and participate in the Lord’s work.
Application (5 min): Have learners write down one family story they want to preserve, one relative they would like to learn more about, or one way they can strengthen a family relationship. Invite them to choose a realistic next step, such as contacting a relative, recording a memory, or researching an ancestor.
Follow-Up Question: What does it mean to turn your heart toward your ancestors, beyond simply learning their names?
Objective: Help learners recognize the Lord’s enduring love and make a personal plan to draw closer to Him through repentance and covenant faithfulness.
Activity Steps:
Introduction (5 min): Write the phrase “I have loved you” on the board. Ask, “Why might someone struggle to recognize God’s love during a difficult season?” Allow learners to reflect without requiring them to share personal experiences. Explain that the Lord’s invitation to Israel offers hope to people who feel spiritually distant.
Scripture Discussion (5 min): Read Malachi 1:2 and Malachi 3:7. Discuss the contrast between Israel’s question, “Wherein hast thou loved us?” and the Lord’s invitation, “Return unto me, and I will return unto you.” Invite learners to identify what these verses teach about God’s character and the purpose of repentance.
Application (5 min): Invite learners to write one private goal for drawing closer to the Lord this week. Examples might include more intentional prayer, studying the scriptures, repairing a relationship, or correcting a habit. Encourage them to choose a specific, achievable action and reflect on their progress later.
Follow-Up Question: How does understanding that the Lord loves us change the way we approach repentance?
Latter-day Saints trust modern prophets because they believe Jesus Christ leads His Church through continuing revelation and priesthood authority. Malachi’s prophecy of Elijah (Malachi 4:5–6) and its fulfillment in Doctrine and Covenants 110:13–16 provide a scriptural foundation for understanding the Restoration. Individuals can study prophetic teachings, compare them with scripture, observe their fruits, and seek personal spiritual confirmation. Trust need not mean assuming that every statement by a Church leader is infallible.
God allows human agency, and mortality provides opportunities to learn, repent, and grow. Scripture teaches that all people fall short and need the Savior’s grace (Romans 3:23–24). God’s love does not eliminate accountability, but through Jesus Christ, mistakes need not define our lives. Malachi 3:7 illustrates this principle by inviting people who have turned away to return to the Lord.

FAIR is a non-profit organization dedicated to providing well-documented answers to criticisms of the doctrine, practice, and history of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.
We are a volunteer organization. We invite you to give back.
Donate Now