• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

FAIR

2022 FAIR Conference videos are now available to watch!

  • Find Answers
  • Blog
  • Media & Apps
  • Conference
  • Bookstore
  • Archive
  • About
  • Get Involved
  • Search

Articles of Faith 8: LDS Church Disciplinary Councils

June 30, 2014 by NickGalieti

https://media.blubrry.com/mormonfaircast/www.fairlatterdaysaints.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/06/AOF-ChurchDiscipline.mp3

Podcast: Download (53.8MB)

Subscribe: RSS

This is a special episode of Articles of Faith. It is special because, our normal focus with the show is on articles written in scholarly journals such as The Interpreter, Square Two, and we have some being lined up to include BYU Studies as well. In this episode we are featuring two articles written on blogs, chosen because of their firsthand experience with church disciplinary councils; one article from the perspective of a person who went through one such council, and the other from the perspective of one who was in a variety of callings that involved being a part of disciplinary councils.

This episode will feature two interviews, one with Barbie Berg, who wrote the article The Truth about an LDS Disciplinary Council. The other is by Allen Wyatt, with his article simply entitled Excommunication. This episode is, in some ways, a response to the events and discourse surrounding the very public church discipline hearing for Kate Kelly.

At the time of these interviews, Kate Kelly has been formally excommunicated for “conduct contrary to the laws and order of the church” and that she “persisted in an aggressive effort to persuade other Church members to your point of view and that your course of action has threatened to erode the faith of others.” Kate Kelly has since declared that she intends to appeal her excommunication. John Dehlin has not yet attended a formal council regarding his possible excommunication.

While an overwhelming majority of church disciplinary councils are not made public, because of the attention that these two have received, largely due to the efforts of Kate Kelly and John Dehlin themselves, we find many asking questions and seeking answers, while others make incorrect, incomplete, or un-Christlike declarations about what disciplinary hearings are, what they mean, how they come to be and how they are to be conducted.

Both of these articles and authors were chosen because, over the course of the weeks surrounding the public announcement of Kelly’s forthcoming church disciplinary council and Dehlin’s possible council, there has been a lot of commentary regarding their circumstances. It is my opinion that much of what was said fell short of the true nature, spirit, and purpose of church disciplinary councils, and I felt it was important to re-align the discourse. It also my opinion that these two articles share a valuable perspective that should be taken into consideration when absorbing and discussing all church disciplinary councils, not just the Kate Kelly scenario.

Barbie Berg: Article – The Truth about an LDS Disciplinary Council

http://barbieannlove.blogspot.com/2014/06/the-truth-about-lds-disciplinary-council.html?m=1

Based on her personal experience with going through a disciplinary council as a younger female as well as her testimony of the spirit that accompanies these councils.

Allen Wyatt: Article – Excommunication

http://www.allenwyatt.com/blog/excommunication

Allen served as a bishop from February 2006 until October 2012. He also served as a branch president, as a counselor in at least three different bishoprics, as a stake executive secretary, and on a high council. In all those positions Allen had the opportunity to sit in on disciplinary councils.

He wrote his article because he was seeing so much vitriol directed against the bishops and stake presidents involved in these matters that he felt someone needed to stand up and say, “no, this is the way it really is.” His article describes just one of the councils that happened to involve the excommunication of a sister.

Filed Under: Articles of Faith, Hosts, Nick Galieti, Podcast

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. valleus says

    July 3, 2014 at 5:27 pm

    One can be a faithful, active LDS who even believes in the importance of FairMormon and regularly donates without needing to strongly defend every single aspect of the Church. When excellent resources, such as FairMormon, produce vigorous defenses of peripheral aspects of the Church, it cheapens the more important defenses of central, core issues.
    Frankly, the way Church disciplinary councils are ran can not reasonably be defended.
    1. Why do different disciplinary councils produce very different results for near similar sins? I have personally witnessed first time, RM regretful fornicators receive excommunication on one hand, and informal probation on the other. Do the apologists for disciplinary councils have any data on the interrater reliability for similar cases? An anecdote as above is charming, but what of the anecdotes that portray councils in a negative light? Does anyone have any actual data?

    2. How can the disciplinary council ever really know why a person did what they did? Do they know if the sinner was abused growing up? Do they know how the confessee’s prefrontal cortex or limbic system is overactive compared to the average? Do they know if the confessee is a good actor going through the motions or truly penitent? How do they know? The answer most frequently given is that as Judges in Israel, the Spirit will give the Truth to the Bishop as to what to do. As there are anecdotes of excellent and poor behavior of disciplinary councils, what is one to do? With something so weighty and precious as your membership in the Church on the line, will you trust it a disciplinary council? Given that the consequences are so heavy, should not a condition for rendering judgment be that the Bishop is inspired in 100% of cases?

    3. Finally, what exactly is the point, or utility of these councils? We know that councils do not absolve sin. A person’s sins are forgiven by the Lord alone, only God knows our hearts. Do councils help those who have ‘seriously’ sinned come back? The incident in the Barbie Berg link is tragic. A less active sister starts to come back, and her Bishop initiates a disciplinary council against her? Is this what the Bishop of Digne did to Valjean? Knowing that a disciplinary council awaits them, would this make it more or less likely that the inactive will take steps to come back? Three of my siblings are inactive. Will a disciplinary council make it more or less likely they will feel welcome if they start to attend church again?

    I am a faithful member, and have wrestled with the above questions for ten years. I have been unable to find answers that speak peace to my conscience.

Primary Sidebar

Subscribe to Blog

Enter your email address:

Subscribe to Podcast

Podcast icon
Subscribe to podcast in iTunes
Subscribe to podcast elsewhere
Listen with FAIR app
Android app on Google Play

Pages

  • Blog Guidelines

FAIR Latest

  • FAIR’s Countdown to Conference – 8 Days!
  • FAIR’s Countdown to Conference – 9 Days!
  • Letter For My Wife Rebuttal, Part 9: The Early Church – The Witnesses [B]
  • FAIR’s Countdown to Conference – 10 Days!
  • The Gospel Brings Life and Immortality to Light

Blog Categories

Recent Comments

  • Robert Martin on Letter For My Wife Rebuttal, Part 9: The Early Church – The Witnesses [B]
  • Mark de St. Aubin on Letter For My Wife Rebuttal, Part 9: The Early Church – The Witnesses [B]
  • Sasha Kwapinski on Come, Follow Me with FAIR: Faithful Answers to New Testament Questions – Matthew 3; Mark 1; Luke 3
  • John E. Enslen on The Gospel Brings Life and Immortality to Light
  • Raymond Takashi Swenson on The Gospel Brings Life and Immortality to Light

Archives

Footer

FairMormon Logo

FAIR is a non-profit organization dedicated to providing well-documented answers to criticisms of the doctrine, practice, and history of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.

Our Friends

  • BYU Religious Studies Center
  • BYU Studies
  • Book of Mormon Central
  • TheFamilyProclamation.org
  • Interpreter Foundation
  • Wilford Woodruff Papers Project

Follow Us

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • iTunes
  • YouTube

Donate to FAIR

We are a volunteer organization. We invite you to give back.

Donate Now

Donate to us by shopping at Amazon at no extra cost to you. Learn how →

Site Footer

Copyright © 1997-2023 by The Foundation for Apologetic Information and Research, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

The views and opinions expressed do not necessarily reflect the views or opinions of FAIR, its officers, directors or supporters.

No portion of this site may be reproduced without the express written consent of The Foundation for Apologetic Information and Research, Inc.

Any opinions expressed, implied, or included in or with the goods and services offered by FAIR are solely those of FAIR and not those of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.

Foundation for Apologetic Information and Research (FAIR) Logo

FAIR is controlled and operated by the Foundation for Apologetic Information and Research (FAIR)