View source for Question: Is it possible that Joseph Smith is not a martyr because, while in jail, he had a gun and he had the temerity to defend himself?

{{Main Page}}
<onlyinclude>
==Question: Is it possible that Joseph Smith is not a martyr because, while in jail, he had a gun and he had the temerity to defend himself?==
===Joseph and Hyrum were martyrs by the accepted definition of the term&mdash;they suffered death for their beliefs===

It seems clear that:

#Joseph and Hyrum were martyrs by the accepted definition of the term&mdash;they suffered death for their beliefs.  (Note that martyrs can die for worthy or ignoble causes, but this makes them no less martyrs.)  
#The Church has not hidden this fact, but published it from the beginning and includes it in the ''History of the Church'' twice.  
#Joseph was not guilty of murder, because no one died from his shots, and his actions would have been justifiable as self-defense and defense of others even if deaths had resulted.

===Critics of Joseph Smith redefine the term "martyr"===

In order to make their argument tenable, the critics must do three things. First, they must take some creative liberties with the English language. In this case, the word being redefined is the term ''martyr''. ''Webster’s New World Dictionary'' defines a "martyr" as 

:“a person who chooses to suffer or die rather than give up his faith or his principles.”<ref>''Webster's New World Dictionary of the American Language'', Second College Edition (New York: World Publishing Company, 1970), 870.</ref>

The online resource, ''Dictionary.com'', defines a martyr as 

<blockquote>
“one who chooses to suffer death rather than renounce religious principles.”<ref>''Dictionary.com'' website, s.v. "[http://dictionary.reference.com/search?q=martyr martyr]."(accessed May 7, 2003).</ref>
</blockquote>

Both are nearly identical and fairly standard definitions, and neither includes a requirement or qualifiers of any sort. However, some anti-Mormon writers have taken the term ''martyr'' and subtly changed its definition to suit their own needs. The new definition would probably read something like this: ''Martyr: a person who chooses to suffer or die rather than give up his faith or his principles without any resistance or effort at self-defense on his part whatsoever''.

Critics are free to use such a definition, but it belongs to them alone; it is not the standard use of the word, and not what Church members mean when they refer to the "martyrdom" of Joseph and Hyrum Smith at Carthage.

Throughout Christian history, "martyrs" have been understood to be those who suffered quietly, and those who resisted, even with violence, and even to the death of those who persecuted them for their beliefs.  

{{Main|Martyrdom in Christian history|l1=Martyrdom in Christian history}}

The first anti-Mormon argument thus focuses on the fact that Joseph had a firearm and that he used that firearm to defend himself. Is it possible that Joseph's announcement that he was going “as a lamb to the slaughter” is false, since he fought back?

Anyone who has ever worked on a farm or in a slaughterhouse knows that sheep do not go willingly
to the slaughter. They kick and buck, bleat, scream, and make every attempt to escape their fate. In fact, they make such a haunting sound, that the title of an extremely popular Hollywood film was based on it: ''The Silence of the Lambs''. The term “lamb to the slaughter” simply refers to the 
inevitability of the final outcome. No matter how valiantly they struggle, the fate of the sheep is sealed. If we apply this understanding to Joseph Smith and his brother, it is clear that they truly were slaughtered like lambs. Fight as they might, they were doomed.

[[Image:Joseph_Gun_at_Carthage.png|thumb|center|400px|''Ensign'' ([http://media.ldscdn.org/pdf/magazines/ensign-june-2013/2013-06-12-two-witnesses-three-days-and-the-aftermath-of-the-martyrdom-eng.pdf June 2013]): 40, shows Joseph with the pepperbox pistol he would fire to defend himself and others prior to his murder.]]
</onlyinclude>
{{endnotes sources}}

<!-- PLEASE DO NOT REMOVE ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE -->
[[Category:The Changing World of Mormonism]]
[[Category:Facts Mormons Won't Tell You]]

[[es:Pregunta: ¿Es posible que José Smith no sea un mártir porque, mientras estaba en la cárcel, tenía una pistola y tenía la temeridad de defenderse?]]
[[Category:Questions]]