• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

FAIR

Faithful Study Resources for Come, Follow Me

  • Find Answers
  • Blog
  • Media & Apps
  • Conference
  • Bookstore
  • Archive
  • About
  • Get Involved
  • Search

Fair Issues 94: Moroni and the Hill Cumorah

August 23, 2015 by Ned Scarisbrick

https://media.blubrry.com/mormonfaircast/www.fairlatterdaysaints.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/Fair-Issues-94-pod.mp3

Podcast: Download (11.0MB)

Subscribe: RSS

MAThe Book of Mormon model for a Mesoamerican geography has – like virtually all scholarly models – a handful of anomalies or potentially problematic issues.  One of those areas of concern legitimately asks how the golden plates could have been dug out of the ground in upstate New York, if Book of Mormon events took place in Mesoamerica.

In this installment brother Ash discusses several possibilities concerning how Moroni may have traveled to deposit the golden plates on the family farm of Joseph Smith.

The full text of this article can be found at Deseret News online.

Brother Ash is author of the book Shaken Faith Syndrome: Strengthening One’s Testimony in the Face of Criticism and Doubt, as well as the book, of Faith and Reason: 80 Evidences Supporting the Prophet Joseph Smith. Both books are available for purchase online through the FairMormon Bookstore. Tell your friends about the Mormon Fair-Cast. Share a link on your Facebook page and help increase the popularity of the Mormon Fair-Cast by subscribing to this podcast in iTunes, and by rating it and writing a review.

The views and opinions expressed in the podcast may not reflect those of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints or that of FairMormon

Filed Under: Apologetics, Book of Mormon, Evidences, Fair Issues, Faith Crisis, General, Geography, Hosts, Joseph Smith, Michael R. Ash, Ned Scarisbrick, Podcast Tagged With: Book of Mormon Geography, Hill Cumorah

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Boanerges Rubalcava says

    August 24, 2015 at 3:30 pm

    Too much for an unnecessary answer. Moroni could do it (transporting everything from Mesoamerica to new York) , by plane (please do not take this literally ) or any other means; he was working under the orders of God. Please, this is not a problem. How did he take them back to wherever are now? The same way he did it from wherever they were before delivered to Joseph Smith.

  2. Opie Tayler says

    August 24, 2015 at 6:25 pm

    The Book of Mormon also refers to the Book of Mormon land as a Land of Liberty.

    2 Nephi 1:7 ” Wherefore, this land is consecrated unto him whom he shall bring. And if it so be that they shall serve him according to the commandments which he hath given, it shall be a land of liberty unto them; wherefore, they shall never be brought down into captivity; if so, it shall be because of iniquity; for if iniquity shall abound cursed shall be the land for their sakes, but unto the righteous it shall be blessed forever.”

    Which country in MesoAmerica fits this description?

  3. Jim Spong says

    August 24, 2015 at 8:13 pm

    The title page of the Book of Mormon states that the book was written to the Lamanites and D&C 3:19-20 states that the plates were preserved ‘that the Lamanites might come to the knowledge of their fathers’. The Lord didn’t waste any time, 6 months after the Book of Mormon was published, in Sept 1830, Oliver Cowdrey was instructed by revelation to go to the Lamanites and preach the gospel. (see D&C 28:8). David Witmer, Peter Whitmer were also called to serve with Oliver to preach to the Lamanites. (see D&C 30:1-8). A month later Parley P Pratt and Ziba Peterson were also called to go ‘unto the wilderness among the Lamanites’. (see D&C 32:2-3). So where did they go? It certainly wasn’t to Mesoamerica. They preached to the Indian Seneca Nation and then along with Frederick G Williams (who joined the church en route) they went to the Shawnees & Delaware Indians.
    If the Lord and Joseph Smith taught that the Lamanites are located in North America; the covenant land of liberty, the land that the Book of Mormon teaches was to be discovered to the world by Columbus followed by the seed of Ephraim from Britain and Europe…..then that’s good enough for me. All this nonsense about 2 Comorah’s creates so much confusion and is not based on scripture.
    The land that is a covenant land that will remain free as long as the people serve the Lord is obviously North America. The Book of Mormon teaches this principle over and over. It was established by inspired men who wrote the constitution. It appears that the constitution is under threat and that the people of North America are in danger of breaking this covenant. For this reason I believe that it is important for church members to understand these principles and the slippery slop America in on right now.

  4. Mike Parker says

    August 24, 2015 at 8:33 pm

    Opie,

    The answer to your question is that no country, anywhere in the Americas, fits that description throughout all history. Even if 2 Nephi 1:7 is referring to the United States of America (which it isn’t; more on that in a second), then how does one explain the fact that from the establishment of the first British colony in America in 1586 until 1776—a period of 190 years—there was no United States and hence no “land of liberty” in the (supposed) Book of Mormon lands? Or how does one explain how the French crown owned the large part of what is now the central U.S. (including Missouri) until the Louisiana Purchase of 1803? And that the entire southwest United States was part of the Republic of Mexico until 1848?

    Looking at 2 Nephi 1 a little more closely reveals that Lehi was speaking to his immediate family “concerning the land of promise, which they had obtained” (1:3). How big was that land? Surely Lehi didn’t have a map of the American continent, with national borders laid out as they would be 2,600 years in his future. In his mind, the “land which the Lord God hath covenanted with me should be a land for the inheritance of my seed” (1:5) would have been the land in his immediate vicinity.

    At this point, his family hadn’t even left the area where their ship had landed to escape the threats of Laman and his followers. When they did flee, they went to a place they called Nephi (2 Nephi 5:5–8). Their descendants left the Land of Nephi for Zarahemla (Omni 1:13), after which the Lamanites fully occupied the Land of Nephi. Was Nephi a “land of liberty” under the Lamanites? Was any place in the Western Hemisphere a land of liberty after the destruction of the Nephites in the time of Mormon and Moroni? The obvious answer is no.

    So narrowly interpreting 2 Nephi 1:7 to refer only to the United States after 1776 (or 1803 or 1848 or 1959) completely removes that verse from context.

    The fact is that Lehi’s promise applies to the entire Western Hemisphere, for, as Joseph Smith taught, “the whole of North and South America is Zion” (Words of Joseph Smith 363; see also History of the Church 6:321, 322). Today, not one country on either continent is ruled by a king; there may be varying levels of liberty between nations, but every one of them has some level of freedom, including the right to worship and to vote.

  5. Mike Parker says

    August 24, 2015 at 11:10 pm

    Jim Spong wrote:

    The title page of the Book of Mormon states that the book was written to the Lamanites and D&C 3:19-20 states that the plates were preserved ‘that the Lamanites might come to the knowledge of their fathers’. The Lord didn’t waste any time, 6 months after the Book of Mormon was published, in Sept 1830, Oliver Cowdrey was instructed by revelation to go to the Lamanites and preach the gospel. (see D&C 28:8). David Witmer, Peter Whitmer were also called to serve with Oliver to preach to the Lamanites. (see D&C 30:1-8). A month later Parley P Pratt and Ziba Peterson were also called to go ‘unto the wilderness among the Lamanites’. (see D&C 32:2-3). So where did they go? It certainly wasn’t to Mesoamerica. They preached to the Indian Seneca Nation and then along with Frederick G Williams (who joined the church en route) they went to the Shawnees & Delaware Indians.

    I think you misunderstand how ancestry and DNA works, Jim. If Lehi, who lived 600 BC, was an ancestor of any Native American living in AD 1830, then he was an ancestor of all of them, across both the North and South American continents. Steve Olson, an expert in population genetics, explains:

    Say you go back 120 generations, to about the year 1000 BC. According to the [statistical] results presented in our Nature paper, your ancestors then included everyone in the world who has descendants living today. And if you compared a list of your ancestors with a list of anyone else’s ancestors, the names on the two lists would be identical.

    This is a very bizarre result (the math behind it is solid, though). It means that you and I are descended from all of the Africans, Australians, Native Americans, and Europeans who were alive three millenniums ago and still have descendants living today.

    This means, Jim, that the Native Americans the first Mormon missionaries preached to on the western frontier of the United States, were, in fact, Lamanites: They were descendants of Laman, just as is every other person with native ancestry in all the Western Hemisphere. And so we have temples throughout Central and South America whose dedicatory prayers have included inspired statements like this one from the Guatemala City Guatemala Temple, dedicated 14–16 December 1984 by President Gordon B. Hinckley:

    Thou kind and gracious Father, our hearts swell with gratitude for Thy remembrance of the sons and daughters of Lehi, the many generations of our fathers and mothers who suffered so greatly and who walked for so long in darkness. Thou hast heard their cries and seen their tears. Now there will be opened to them the gates of salvation and eternal life.

    Jim continues:

    If the Lord and Joseph Smith taught that the Lamanites are located in North America; the covenant land of liberty, the land that the Book of Mormon teaches was to be discovered to the world by Columbus followed by the seed of Ephraim from Britain and Europe…..then that’s good enough for me.

    Christopher Columbus never set foot anywhere near the land that is the United States today:

    Columbus' voyages

    However, on his fourth and final voyage, he visited modern-day Honduras, Nicaragua, Costa Rica, and Panama. While in Honduras he met and traded with Mayans from the Yucatan.

    Jim:

    All this nonsense about 2 Comorah’s creates so much confusion and is not based on scripture.

    There are not two Cumorahs. There is one hill Cumorah, the one described in the Book of Mormon, into which the prophet Mormon “hid up…all the records which had been entrusted to me by the hand of the Lord, save it were these few plates which I gave unto my son Moroni” (Mormon 6:6).

    In other words, the plates of Mormon were not hidden in the hill Cumorah; all the other plates Mormon had were. It was only because of a misreading of the Book of Mormon by early Latter-day Saints that the drumlin near Joseph Smith’s home in New York came to be called “Cumorah.” (Even though it isn’t the Cumorah of the Book of Mormon, it’s still a fitting tribute to that great hill where the Nephites made their last stand.)

    Jim:

    The land that is a covenant land that will remain free as long as the people serve the Lord is obviously North America. The Book of Mormon teaches this principle over and over.

    Yes, and South America too, as Joseph Smith taught.

    Jim:

    It was established by inspired men who wrote the constitution. It appears that the constitution is under threat and that the people of North America are in danger of breaking this covenant. For this reason I believe that it is important for church members to understand these principles and the slippery slop America in on right now.

    Your concluding statement explains the current fad of insisting that the Book of Mormon took place inside the United States: It’s driven by patriotic nationalism, not by a close and careful reading of the text of the Book of Mormon.

Primary Sidebar

Subscribe to Blog

Enter your email address:

Subscribe to Podcast

Podcast icon
Subscribe to podcast in iTunes
Subscribe to podcast elsewhere
Listen with FAIR app
Android app on Google Play Download on the App Store

Pages

  • Blog Guidelines

FAIR Latest

  • Come, Follow Me with FAIR – Doctrine and Covenants 49–50 – Autumn Dickson
  • By This All Will Know That You Are My Disciples
  • Come, Follow Me with FAIR – Doctrine and Covenants 46, 49–50, 52–56 – Mike Parker
  • Come, Follow Me with FAIR – Doctrine and Covenants 46–48 – Autumn Dickson
  • As a Little Child

Blog Categories

Recent Comments

  • Ana on Come, Follow Me with FAIR – Doctrine and Covenants 45 – Autumn Dickson
  • Kal- El Luke Skywalker on As a Little Child
  • Ned Scarisbrick on An Easter Message from FAIR
  • Sad Mom on Mortality Works: Finding Meaning in Life’s Challenges
  • Arogen on Are you a personal revelation weirdo?

Archives

Footer

FairMormon Logo

FAIR is a non-profit organization dedicated to providing well-documented answers to criticisms of the doctrine, practice, and history of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.

Our Friends

  • BYU Religious Studies Center
  • BYU Studies
  • Book of Mormon Central
  • TheFamilyProclamation.org
  • Interpreter Foundation
  • Wilford Woodruff Papers Project

Follow Us

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • iTunes
  • YouTube
Android app on Google Play Download on the App Store

Donate to FAIR

We are a volunteer organization. We invite you to give back.

Donate Now

Site Footer

Copyright © 1997-2025 by The Foundation for Apologetic Information and Research, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

The views and opinions expressed do not necessarily reflect the views or opinions of FAIR, its officers, directors or supporters.

No portion of this site may be reproduced without the express written consent of The Foundation for Apologetic Information and Research, Inc.

Any opinions expressed, implied, or included in or with the goods and services offered by FAIR are solely those of FAIR and not those of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.

Foundation for Apologetic Information and Research (FAIR) Logo

FAIR is controlled and operated by the Foundation for Apologetic Information and Research (FAIR)